A new film version of Roald Dahl’s novel The Witches has been criticised for its depictions of limb difference.
The film, which stars Anne Hathaway, features evil characters who have distinct hand and feet impairments.
Comedian Alex Brooker, who has hand and arm impairments, told the BBC that the images “jarred quite a lot” and could “add to the stigma” around disability.
Film studio Warner Bros said it was “deeply saddened” to learn the movie “could upset people with disabilities”.
In a statement, the company said: “It was never the intention for viewers to feel that the fantastical, non-human creatures were meant to represent them”.
Directed by Robert Zemeckis, The Witches is the second big-screen version of Dahl’s novel about disguised witches plotting to turn children into mice.
In the original book, the witches are described as having “thin curvy claws” instead of fingernails, and feet that “have square ends with no toes on them at all”.
‘What sort of message does this give?’
In the new film, Anne Hathaway’s Grand High Witch and others are revealed to have three elongated fingers on each hand.
A trailer for the film also features a lesson on “how to identify witches” that highlights their “claws” and lack of toes.
The Witches had originally been set for a cinema release but, following the Covid-19 pandemic, was distributed on digital platforms last month. Shortly afterwards, the hashtag #NotAWitch began trending on social media.
Brooker said that when he first watched the film he was expecting “something very different” beneath the witches’ gloves.
“It clearly looked like they’d removed some of the fingers,” he told BBC reporter Matt Graveling. “I was like, ‘I’m not sure that’s on’.
“What sort of message does this give? To me It sends out a message that we should be scared of people with missing fingers.
“A lot of kids and adults have that – that’s a life people live. It doesn’t need to add to the stigma.”
Actress and TV presenter Grace Mandeville said she was “really disappointed with the decision to give the villains in the movie a disability for absolutely no reason other than to make the character seem scarier”.
She told BBC News: “The truth is children will watch this movie and some will then be scared of people that have limb impairments or ectrodactyly [a split hand] thanks to this film.
“I thought we were moving forward in this industry, but once again a movie has used scars and a disability to create a scary character.”
She added: “I’m aware that this is just a movie to some people, but this affects the perception of disabled people more than you’ll realise.
“I dread to think how a class of children would react to a new classmate who has a scar or a limb impairment after they’ve all watched this film.”
UK Paralympic swimmer and Para-triathlete Claire Cashmore was among the others who warned that the film could have a negative effect.
Cashmore, who was born without a left forearm, said images of Hathaway’s character had left her “very confused/upset”, and suggested Warner Bros should have sought feedback before making the film.
“We want disabilities to be normalised and be represented in a positive light rather than [be] associated with being a scary, evil witch,” she wrote on Instagram.
View this post on Instagram
‘Your arm is so scary’ ‘Your arm makes me feel sick’ . . These are just a few comments I received growing up. As a self conscious youngster these comments hurt ALOT and would knock my confidence. Nowadays I just feel sorry for the very ignorant people.🤷♀️ . . Seeing this picture from the ‘The Witches’ film made me very confused/upset. Yes you could say it’s great to see someone with a limb difference on TV and more than anything I really want to see more representation in the media. However we want disabilities to to be normalised and be represented in a positive light rather than being associated with being a scary, evil, witch. I know a lot of children and adults who are born missing their fingers and I want them to know that this does not represent you. Your limb difference is not scary. Your difference is unique and beautiful and should be celebrated. . . Some may think that the limb difference community is being over sensitive. But have you lived your life trying to overcome a stigma? . . . I really don’t believe that @warnerbrosuk would have wanted to upset or cause offence but I think maybe a few more discussions should have been had. . More than happy to hear your opinions as I think it’s great to be able to have open discussions about such topics. #notawitch
British Paralympic swimmer Amy Marren also criticised the film for showing “something that makes a person different” in a scary or monstrous light.
Former Coronation Street actress Melissa Johns, who was recently seen in BBC One drama Life, said “using disability as a costume and to highlight a character as a ‘baddie'” was “not what we need”.
The charity Reach has also criticised the film, saying it had left “members of the upper limb difference community… appalled and devastated”.
In its statement, Warner Bros said it had “worked with designers and artists to come up with a new interpretation of the cat-like claws that are described in the book”.